Who Watches The Watchers?

Are ratings agencies fatally conflicted?

During the financial crisis the credit-rating agencies came under heavy fire for giving AAA ratings to subprime conduits that later experienced losses. Calpers and other investors filed lawsuits, alleging that the agencies knew, or should have known, that the bonds they rated were junk.

The ratings agencies are supposed to tell investors how creditworthy a borrower is. The three largest agencies—Moody’s, S&P, and Fitch—control 90% of the market. They operate under an issuer-pays approach: the issuer engages one or more agencies; the agency conducts its due diligence and publishes a rating; and investors use this rating to help them evaluate the bonds. Ratings are publically available, free of charge, to all investors. The ratings provide a standardized reference point for portfolio managers.

There’s a conflict: borrowers pay the agencies to have the agencies tell the world what they think of the borrower. But the alternatives—user pays, or public funding—have their own problems: agency costs, or lack of visibility. Unless you subscribe to Morningstar, you don’t know their ratings. They don’t put out press releases. And internal ratings, which professional money-managers like Charter use, aren’t much good for public policy purposes..

The ratings agencies are the guardians of the credit market. But who will guard the guardians?

Douglas R. Tengdin, CFA

Chief Investment Officer

By | 2014-03-18T09:48:09+00:00 March 18th, 2014|Global Market Update|0 Comments

About the Author:

Mr. Tengdin is the Chief Investment Officer at Charter Trust Company and author of “The Global Market Update”. The audio version of each post can be heard on radio stations throughout New England every weekday. Mr. Tengdin graduated from Dartmouth College, Magna Cum Laude. He received his Master of Arts from Trinity Divinity School, Magna Cum Laude and received his Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) designation in 1992. Mr. Tengdin has been managing investment portfolios for over 30 years, working for Bank of Boston, State Street Global Advisors, Citibank – Tunisia, and Banknorth Group. Throughout his career, Mr. Tengdin has emphasized helping clients manage their financial risks in difficult environments where they can profit from investing in diverse assets in diverse settings. - Leave a comment if you have any questions—I read them all! - And Follow me on Twitter @GlobalMarketUpd

Leave A Comment