The game is rigged.
That’s one lesson from MF Global. Because brokerage accounts are designed by and for the broker, customers agree to all kinds of things without knowing what they’re signing up for. One of these is margin—by borrowing against your securities, you give the broker the right to use your securities for other purposes. Another is securities-lending, where the brokerage can lend out the customer’s stocks or bonds to a short-seller, in exchange for cash which can earn a small spread.
The thing is, many brokerage customers agree to these provisions without knowing it. Lots of accounts are in an “opt-out” form, like Facebook privacy settings. So unless clients tell the firm otherwise, their own securities can be used to “hypothecate” the broker’s own positions. And dealers who receive those securities can re-hypothecate them to cover their own borrowing.
Thus is violated one of the primary principles of fiduciary conduct: the customer’s assets must remain dedicated to the customer’s purposes. The same assets are pledged against multiple loans, and if the firm fails before the loans are unwound, the customer goes to the back of the line as a senior unsecured creditor.
This is all disclosed—in 6-point type at the back of a brokerage agreement that you need a microscope to read. It’s another reason why all our accounts are cash accounts—no borrowing is done, and no one borrows against our client funds. Because when it comes to customer cash, the rule is simple: it’s their money.
Douglas R. Tengdin, CFA
Chief Investment Officer
Hit reply if you have any questions—I read them all!
Follow me on Twitter @GlobalMarketUpd